Composite Toe VS Steel Toe, Which is the right choice for you? and whats the difference?



Going head to head is the Composite Toe and the Steel Toe. Well, the champion will depend on your industry of work. In order to determine the one that is most suitable for you, you first need to gain some understanding about the dissimilarities between them both and their reasons for existence.


Composite Toe VS. Steel Toe Composite Toes


In terms of providing protection for the toes, composite toes are new to this type of thing. Composite stands as a scientific term which portrays that no metal is contained in them and are constructed from materials like rubbers, carbon fiber and plastic.


Steel Toes


Protection for the toes has been a long-term task for steel toes. It is basically a super-sturdy section of steel that covers the toes. This hinders any heavy object to fall on the toes and damage them.


Myth or Reality? “If The Steel Toe Snaps It Can Cut Off Your Toes”


A story has been around of a male who experienced great pain after a heavy object fell on his feet and broke the steel cap. His toes were severed during the proceedings.

Well, this one was clearly explained by the “Myth busters”. That’s a must-see episode. Check out the results here:


Myth busted!


“Using similar tests to those used to test steel toe boot certification, Adam and Jamie determine that your toes are much safer with steel toe boots than without. There was no toe-cutting curling of the steel toe, and even using a blade attachment didn’t work, only glancing off the steel toe to cut right above where it ended” (


So, which is the better one?


The main purpose of composite and steel toes is to protect your toes from being damaged if something should fall on them. In fact, they carry out this task very well!

They are both given approval by OHSA. Remember that? Therefore, you’ll be safeguarded from electrical hazards and impacts. However, there are some advantages and disadvantages of both. These are listed below:


Advantages of Steel Toes

1. Shatterproof
2. Puncture protection 3. Cost-effective


Advantages of Composite Toes

1. More enhanced electrical resistance.
2. Lightweight
3. Provide excellent insulation in low-temperature climates. 4. Do not trigger off metal detectors.


Disadvantages of Steel Toes

1. Trigger off metal detectors.
2. Weigh more.
3. Provide low insulation in low-temperate climates.


Disadvantages of Composite Toes

1. More on the expensive side.
2. Do not provide great puncture protection.


It all comes down to a few things that you should consider:

  1. Is there a great quantity of puncture of nails in the vicinity?Select steel toes.
  2. How frequently do you pass through a metal detector? Selectcomposite toes if it’s frequent.
  3. What degree of weight does the equipment being handled has? Select steel toes if it’s extremely heavy.
  4. Do you work in extremely cold climates? Choose composite toes to get better insulation.


Boots that have composite toes are most suitable if you have to walk through metal detectors on a daily basis. Unlike steel toes, they won’t trigger off the detectors. The other advantages that are listed above all come as a bonus.


Contrastingly, steel toes are most appropriate for working environments where the possibility of your work boots getting punctured by an object is really high. These objects include rubble, glass, nails etc.


Therefore, when picking out work boots, ensure that you choose the one that will give you the highest level of toe protection. The more protection your toes receive from that particular work boot, it’s the more suitable the work boot will be for you.


So, now since you’ve garnered a basic understanding, here are some top-rated composite-toe and steel-toe work boots for you to select from:



Best Rated Composite Toe Boots Irish Setter Men’s 6′′ Aluminum Toe Work Boot






The Irish Setter brand is comparatively new to the work boot market. However, they have managed to stay afloat by offering fairly good performance to customers to keep them happy. It’s that simple!


The Irish Setter is equipped with a safety toe which is made from aluminum. Because of this construction, they provide excellent safeguarding for your toes without transporting heat or cold and are very lightweight.


Beyond that, they are very cost-effective and carry a great appearance. They are undoubtedly an unregretful investment.


Carhartt Men’s 6 Inch Composite Toe Boot






These composite toe work boots are no strangers to the wide range of comfortable and durable work boots that Carhartt is renowned for. The main reasons why these work boots are so highly favored by the public are the cost and value that they provide.


Customarily, you’ll find that composite boots are a little more on the expensive side when compared to steel toe work boots. Subsequently, you’ll certainly be contented with the fairly reasonable price of these work boots. In fact, they are less expensive that your typical work boots. Talk about a great bargain!



Timberland PRO Men’s 6 Inch Boondock Comp Toe WP Insulated Industrial Work Boot






Being a part of Timberland Pro’s most prized work boot collection, the Boondocks never fail to deliver great performance, durability and comfort to customers; which is one of the reasons why they are so appreciated.


This work boot stands out among the other two in review because of a supplementary thick rubber safety layer which covers the composite toe. This means that the composite toe can never be exposed regardless of how much you try to wear the boots down. There is also a water-resistant and an insulation layer to allow your feet to remain protected, warm and dry at all times.


So, if you’re in search of a pair of work boots with a composite toe that helps you to keep warm, look no further than these work boots.



Best Rated Composite Toe Boots Timberland Pro Pitboss Steel Toe Boot






The Timberland Pro Pitboss is greatly appreciated by us. In point of fact, it stands as our most highly-rated inclusive work boot because of its different features. These include its durability and wide steel toe which offers excellent protection to your toes.


We could discuss this boot all day long but all in all, if a steel toe is what you’re in search of, there’s a high possibility that your safety is of great importance to you. Subsequently, your first choice should be these work boots. Packed into this rigid work boot are an amazing combination of comfort, durability, and safety.



Keen Utility Men’s Atlanta Cool Steel Toe Work Shoe







On Amazon, this work boot stands as one that customers tend to love! Besides, there are several reasons for this. For one, it offers a steel toe which keeps your toes safeguarded. Simultaneously, its low cut design gives your feet great comfort and space to breathe. It is possible that you require a steel toe but not the other features of a typical construction work boot. Given that that’s the case, you’ve found what you’ve been searching for – a safe, comfortable and compact work boot with irresistible pricing.



Thorogood Men’s American Heritage 6-Inch Steel-Toe Boot






Are you in search of a work boot with steel toe but you’re not intrigued by the style of the other two options above? Well, there’s a steel toe option that comes with the Thorogood American Heritage which provides you with unimaginable safety!


Read our review of the Thorogood American Heritage right here to discover the big picture of this boot and disclose the reasons behind its reign as one of the most comfortable work boots that can be found on the market. In comparison to the other two above, this boot is more expensive. However, without losing out on safety, you get amazing comfort and style.